While working at Purdue University, one of the kits I used for detection of Horseradish Peroxidase/Western blots was Pierce’s ECL Substrate. I had the opportunity to use Pierce’s ECL reagent for viewing proteins which reacted with the primary antibody SC-95555, against Clara Cell protein CC10, from Santa Cruz Biotechnology. The antibody is a rabbit polyclonal recognizing 1-96 aa of mouse Clara Cell protein. I previously discussed the related work with
my review of the Amersham ECL Advanced™. I used a secondary from Zymed: a goat anti-rabbit, subclass-balanced antibody conjugated to horseradish perioxidase. The initial experiments consisted of a comparison of rat lung homogenates, mouse Clara Cell isolates, with Biovendor’s human CC10 and Abnova Human recombinant CC10 as controls. The mouse Clara Cell isolate proteins were isolated from the cytosols of murine Clara Cells. Samples were run on a 15 % SDS-PAGE and transferred to Millipore Immobilon PVDF membrane, 0.22 micron pore size.
Pierce’s ECL reagent kit has two solutions which are mixed in equal proportions after the reagents are warmed to room temperature. I performed 90 second film exposures. The signal generation is slower than with ECL Advanced™ (GE Healthcare). The signal to noise ratio is extremely respectable ~5-10:1. The polyclonal had a ~3:2 signal to noise ratio due to non-specific binding with other proteins. When I loaded 1 ug of recombinant CC10 into each well of the gel, this amount was easily recognized. In this instance, my polyclonal showed minimal non-specific reactivity. The amount of protein loaded onto the gel: 0.5, 1 or 10 ug of total protein, was determined by the BCA assay. It is my opinion that because of the high proportion of carbohydrates in Clara Cell isolates, the BCA assay is not an appropriate choice for protein estimation. In the studies with ECL Advanced™, we used relative number of cells.
Although I cannot address the absolute sensitivity limits of Pierce’s ECL™ reagent, in my hands, with Amersham ECL Advanced™, I was able to detect roughly 2.1 X 10-11 - 1.26 X 10-9 grams of CC10 protein and found Pierce’s ECL reagents to be about 3 – 8 fold less sensitive. Due to the fact I was working with cell isolates and there can be variations from animal to animal as well as other variables, precise statements about sensitivity are extremely difficult to make (numerous calculation approximations were made). However, I can state that signal generation was much slower with Pierce’s ECL™ and showed less zip (turnover rate/unit area membrane) and pep (amount of light produced/exposure) than GE Healthcare’s ECL Advanced™ reagents.
For these reasons, if you are measuring small relative changes in protein levels, another detection system may be best suited for your measurements. However, with all other types of samples, Pierce’s ECL™ is a wonderful choice.
I found the system to be easy to use. In addition, Pierce’s ECL™ reagents are very cost effective.
Former Scientist II
Division Biochemical/Diagnostics
Boehringer Mannheim