RNA-seq is increasingly used for quantitative profiling of small RNAs in diverse sample types, however the accuracy and reproducibility of the currently used small RNA-seq library preparation methods has been problematic.

"Different people are using different methods to sequence small RNA, and sometimes getting different results. If it keeps going on like that, it will be hard for the field to make progress," says Muneesh Tewari, M.D., Ph.D., professor of internal medicine and biomedical engineering at Michigan Medicine and one of the authors on a paper published today in Nature Biotechnology explaining the study and findings.

Tewari's lab led a group of nine labs across the United States and the Netherlands that tested nine different methods for RNA sequencing to understand and standardize the best way to sequence small RNAs. The goal was to create a process that could be reproduced from one lab to the next.

Subscribe to eNewsletters
Get the latest industry news and technology updates
related to your research interests.

They were particularly focused on the use of RNA sequencing in liquid biopsies. "Liquid biopsy for RNA is an exciting new field for diagnostics. But the field needed this kind of consortium to come together, because of the challenge of different methods leading to results that are not reproducible," Tewari says.

Each lab used multiple testing protocols to sequence four different samples, including a plasma sample and three synthetic RNA samples. Altogether, they tested nine different sequencing protocols, including four commercially available kits and five protocols developed by the labs. The combined data yielded more than 5 billion sequencing reads.

Researchers found that different methods used for sequencing produced different, often inaccurate, estimates of how abundant any individual marker was. The methods developed by the consortium labs improved the accuracy of these estimates. When RNA sequencing was used to compare the relative amounts of individual microRNAs between different samples, however, all the methods produced accurate and reproducible estimates.

"We found there was not a lot of variability if you used the same protocol across multiple labs," says study author Ryan Spengler, Ph.D., a post-doctoral fellow in Tewari's lab. "This means, if you want to coordinate a study between different labs, the key is to keep to the same protocol—whatever it is. Then you can compare your results."