What do you do when the alarm won’t stop ringing on your biosafety cabinet? If your first response is to close the window and hope that solves the problem, you are not alone and, in most cases, are probably not causing any harm. However, if the incessant clamor flusters you and you start moving your arms around rapidly in the BSC, you might be making the situation worse, especially if you are working with infectious materials or hazardous chemicals.
Although most BSCs come with detailed instructions on dealing with problems and best practices for responding to alarms, not everyone has access to or interest in reading the instrument manual. Much like the automobile manual, BSC instructions often sit in a secure place unopened and underappreciated. These days, laboratory instruments, like cars, are supposed to be easy to use with intuitive features to guide users. Unfortunately, these features aren’t always intuitive, and training is often inadequate or nonexistent.
Early BSC control panels were pretty basic, driven largely by what engineers could figure out how to do. They featured on/off switches, circuit breakers, and a flashing red alarm light. As control panels evolved, icons were added for alarms, lights, outlets, and fans. Early icons were often designed for engineers as well and were not always easily interpreted.
Current BSC interfaces are more user-friendly and easier to understand, but for the most part, BSC operators still lack guidance on what to do when an audible or visible alarm is triggered. The consequences of not responding to a BSC alarm quickly and properly include loss of valuable reagents and samples as well as significant safety concerns. It is increasingly recognized that operators need more comprehensive training on these popular but little understood instruments. With a wide range of triggers and appropriate responses, better training in how to respond to BSC alarms is a pressing need.
Window position alarm
The most commonly triggered alarm is the window position alarm. In order to maintain airflow balance, BSC window sashes need to be kept at a specified height. Unbalanced airflow velocities can increase risks to operators when dealing with infectious materials and undermine precise experimental conditions such as those required in cell culture.
According to NSF/ANSI 49-2018, proper BSC technique includes ensuring that the window sash is at the proper height. A sash that’s positioned too high or low can leave the worker constantly reaching up and down, churning the interior air and increasing the chance of handling errors and contamination.
Window alarms are pretty easy to manage by keeping the window at a proper height. Most BSC users figure this out rapidly and find the sweet spot where they can work safely and comfortably without triggering the alarm.
Inflow alarms
Cabinet inflow rates vary among BSCs, but no matter the cabinet and inflow rate, the same amount of air that went into the BSC must go out. Maintaining that airflow balance can be challenging, so some labs request an inflow alarm. Since it is difficult to measure inflow directly, this alarm is often a sensor at the exhaust opening that measures BSC exhaust. If the inflow alarm is triggered, the best course of action is to immediately minimize any potential exposure to biological hazards while moving smoothly and gently so as to minimize turbulence in the window opening of the cabinet. If there are open samples, cover or close them. Withdraw from the cabinet, and if it has a sliding window and can operate with a closed window, close the window. Now that the risk of exposure is minimized, determine the reason for the alarm.
External exhaust alarms
If users are not working with dangerous gases, filtered BSC exhaust can be safely vented into the room and external exhaust is not necessary. However, if hazardous chemicals are being used, a cabinet with external exhaust is mandated. When an external exhaust alarm sounds and hazardous chemicals are being used, users should stop working and follow safety guidelines. In most cases, the unit will shut down within 15 to 20 seconds.
Canopy alarms
Canopy alarms monitor the airflow passing through the canopy and determine whether it is sufficient to capture the exhaust air from the BSC. When airflow is disrupted (typically because an exhaust fan has failed), the alarm will sound, alerting the user that they have lost containment of exhaust. Remember the exhaust from the BSC is filtered and does not carry any biological hazards. However, it might have volatile toxic chemical gas.
If not working with volatile toxic chemicals, users may not need to act immediately but should finish up and determine the reason for the alarm. If working with volatile toxic chemicals in the cabinet, immediately minimize any potential exposure to chemical hazards from the exhaust while moving smoothly and gently to maintain containment at the window opening of the cabinet. If there are open containers with the volatile toxic chemicals, cover or close them. It may not be necessary to close the window, as the closed containers will prevent the release of additional toxic chemicals into the cabinet airflow and exhaust. Once the risk of exposure is minimized, determine the reason for the alarm.
Because every lab is unique and has different class BSCs and associated protocols, it makes sense to regularly provide training to users as well as to post best practices for dealing with BSC failures and alarms in a prominent place so they can be easily referenced when needed. These guidelines should include something resembling a decision tree that covers appropriate responses for problems within different BSCs as well as a range of alarm-triggering scenarios. In addition, an emergency point of contact within the lab or organization or at the vendor/service provider should be provided.
Five Safety Tips
David Phillips, senior global product technology specialist, clean air, at Thermo Fisher Scientific, likes the BSC/car analogy and recommends that BSC operators be given simple, succinct guidelines like the invaluable “steer into the skid” defensive driving tip. Here are 5 easy-to-follow and easy-to-remember suggestions from Phillips that will help you stay safe when working in a biosafety cabinet.
What to do when BSC alarm rings
1. Don’t panic and wave hands around
2. Gently cover exposed material
3. Secure the work area, gently and calmly pull hands out, and close window
4. Take gloves off, step away from cabinet, and wash hands
5. Deal with situation calmly