NEB's Gel Extraction Kit

Universite de Montreal
Neurocience
Research associate

Overall

Quality of Results

Ease-of-Optimization

What do these ratings mean?
Write a Review

Company:

New England Biolab

Product Name:

Monarch DNA Gel Extraction Kit

Catalog Number:

T1020S

The format is simple and appealing. The procedure fast. Unfortunately, in my hands, the DNA obtained is not clean. It always contamination at 220-230 nm, even higher than the pick at 260 nm. Probably Guanidine from the gel binding buffer, Therefore a DNA clean up step is necessary before using the DNA.

Experimental Design and Results Summary

Application

Gel purification of DNA for cloning

Starting Material

PCR products or plasmid DNA inside an agarose gel

Protocol Overview

The gel is cut and dissolved at 50C in a binding buffer containing Guanidine thiocyanate and sodium iodide. The mix is loaded into a column and then washed with an Ethanol-based buffer. Finally, the DNA is eluted in a very small volume (as low as 6 ul)

Tips

The DNA has to be cleaned again using the Monarch PCR & DNA Cleanup Kit

Results Summary

I have tried to optimize the extraction following all suggestions in this list from the manufacturer:

1 Melt your agarose completely

2 Minimize exposure to UV light

3 Use the smallest agarose plug possible

4 Ensure there is no ethanol in your eluate (adding an extra spin to dry)

5 Use the recommended amount of Dissolving Buffer

I also tested:

6 Adding an extra wash step

7 Washing with double the amount of wash buffer

8 Rinsing the sides of the column when adding the wash buffer. The contamination at around 220 is still there.

DOI or PMID #

N/A

Additional Notes

If you are stuck with this kit, you can add the extra step with Monarch PCR & DNA Cleanup Kit. You just elute from the Monarch DNA Gel Extraction Kit in 20 ul and proceed with the next protocol. Elute in only 6 ul. In the picture I attached, I combined 2 gel extractions of the same insert in this last step (note that the final concentration looks the same). I lost aprox. 50% of the DNA, but still had enough for the ligation.

Image Gallery

Summary

The Good

The low elution volume

The Bad

DNA obtained is contaminated

The Bottom Line

I wouldn't recommend this kit, until NEB makes a 2.0 version w/o the contamination problem. I a waiting for it! because the low elution volume is great!

Join the discussion